By all accounts the speech, which I didn’t watch, was a flop. Certainly the hard-right sites like Breitbart reported Trump’s claims as gospel. Fox News — having had to pay $787 million to Dominion Voting Systems — reported it carefully and with a notable lack of enthusiasm. The rest of media tore it apart. There was a lot of real-time fact checking, I understand.
Today’s follow up from Homeland Security secretary Markwayne Mullin was nonetheless disturbing. Mullin is threatening states that don’t comply with Trump’s “election security” measures, which includes a demand that states run their voter rolls through a federal database maintained by DHS to determine which voters are and are not allowed to vote. Today he ramped up the pressure:
“If the election officials, once we gave them the information they need to secure their elections, and they chose not to, then those individuals can also be held accountable by fines, by penalties and even, depending on how far it goes, prison time,” Mr. Mullin said.
The speech may have been a joke, but the plans are not.
One of the most interesting takes on the speech is from David Frum at The Atlantic, Trump Dooms His Own Party.
If you are an anti-Trump voter who watched all or part of tonight’s speech to the nation, you saw a president removed from reality, babbling about conspiracy theories, threatening your right to vote. You probably came away from the speech alarmed, angry, and motivated.
If, on the other hand, you are pro-Trump, you heard a message of despair. Your president, in whom you trust, described a hopelessly compromised voting system, so broken that it fooled even Trump himself in his first presidency. Between the Chinese, the illegal aliens, and the hated liberal media, your vote will probably count for nothing. Plus, it’s crooked and unpatriotic to vote by mail. It’s all hopeless. Why bother?
Frum recalls that a few years ago Trump’s incessant whining about the “fake” and “rigged” 2020 elections helped hand both of Georgia’s U.S. Senate seats to Democrats. And Trump’s speech last night was entirely about Trump and his own grievances. It did the Republican candidates facing the midterms no good at all. In Trump’s mind he possibly thought his speech might get the SAVE America Act passed, but I still don’t think it has the votes in the Senate. Frum concludes,
Trump is always about Trump first. Tonight was about Trump alone. He’s abandoned his allies because it’s his nature; he cannot help it. Soon he’ll discover what it’s like to be even more isolated and embattled than he needed to be, because he could not speak for—or about—anything other than himself.
There are a lot of things Trump could do to help his party win the midterm elections. He could talk about issues voters care about. He might even have allowed the Republicans to have their big signing ceremony over the housing bill that quietly became law last week without Trump’s signature. Instead, he called it a “yawn.” But Trump can’t be bothered. Yet he’s frantic to get the SAVE America Act passed because he thinks it will win the midterms for Republicans (I have questions about that, but let’s go on).
Something Chris Hayes has said several times is that Trump would rather cheat than win. I dimly remember Mary Trump saying something along those lines, too. Basically, he doesn’t see why he should have to do the work when he can find a way to cheat and get what he wants. It’s a lifelong pattern with him. Campaigning was fun for him in 2016, especially the big rallies, but those don’t seem to work for him as well any more. Whether he will have campaign rallies with candidates as we get closer to the November election I cannot say. Whether Republican candidates want him to rally with them I cannot say, either.
Now he just wants to stuff his pockets and build monuments to himself and not be bothered with the governing thing. One would think he’s paying attention to his war in Iran, but it’s hard to say. There are reports today that the U.S. has escalating bombing, destroying bridges and an airport. Oh, and the Strait of Hormuz is closed. I assume Trump has signed off on the bombing. But he’s not saying what he hopes to gain. The ever-shifting reasons he started the war in the first place seem to have fallen away. He’s stuck in it because he doesn’t know how to get out of it without looking like a loser.
And because oil prices will no doubt go up, the economy will be screwed for the foreseeable future. And into the midterms. Republicans must see this.
And some of them may see that the SAVE America Act would suppress Republican votes as well as Democratic ones. A few of them anyway.
David Graham also wrote about the speech at The Atlantic. See Trump’s Plan for November Is Failing.
The speech was a sign of desperation. Trump spoke now not only to distract from his sputtering Iran war and its effects on the economy, but also because his attempts to concretely interfere with the 2026 election thus far have almost all failed. As his opportunities to change the rules of the game before November slip away from him, the president is falling back on one of the few tools he has left: attempting to sow chaos and doubt among Americans.
He’s not desperate enough to do his job as President, of course. That’s probably just as well. It’s way over his head,

